Organic Mattresses vs. Traditional Mattresses

There are many things to consider when purchasing a new mattress. You want to be sure to choose a mattress that is both comfortable and affordable. Some people approach mattress shopping with other requirements, including materials to keep you cool in summer and warm in winter, and support that is specific to an individual’s needs regarding back, neck, or joint pain.

What many people don’t take time to think about, however, are the materials that make up the mattress. Organic mattresses and traditional mattresses both have a great selection of sizes, firmness, and support. However, what separates them is the materials. This guide will help you make an informed decision about the materials used to make up your mattress and offers information on their purpose. As always, the best way to gather information is to test out a variety of organic and traditional mattresses in one of our showrooms before making a final decision.

Materials Used in Organic Mattresses

Organic mattresses are made of materials that are free from pesticides and other toxins. Some organic mattresses are even produced with materials from eco-friendly farms, ensuring the materials are safe for the sleeper as well as the environment. Here are a few of the most commonly used organic mattress materials:

Latex

When latex is 100% natural, it is made from the sap emitted by rubber trees and does not include any additives. An organic latex mattress will include at least 95% rubber, but many are actually a combination of latex and other fillers. When it comes to comfort, there are very few differences between natural latex and synthetic or hybrid latex mattresses. In fact, natural latex mattresses are revered for their durability. Of all the different types of mattresses to choose from, these last the longest.

When looking for a soft organic mattress, you’ll want natural talalay latex. It’s a strong and durable form of latex great for offering both comfort and support. It’s allergen-free, removes static electricity, and has natural cooling properties so hot sleepers can rest comfortably.

Wool

Wool is a great addition to an organic mattress and perfect for a sleeper who tends to run hot. It may seem counterintuitive, but organic wool actually cools the body as it sleeps. In fact, wool is comprised of air pockets that allow for increased circulation within the mattress. Many organic mattresses contain a layer of wool but be aware that mattresses made up primarily of wool will not last very long as the material is not as durable as other organic materials.

Cotton

Organic cotton is the main ingredient of an organic mattress. Whether it’s used as filler or as a casing around the interior materials, cotton is essential to producing a firm or medium-firm mattress. Cotton batting has the perfect balance of support and softness, so those who need a plush mattress they can sink into will love it. Meanwhile, knit cotton as the casing is durable, soft, and breathable, leading to a more restful sleep for many.

Horse Hair

Long-strand mane and tail horse hair might sound unconventional, but it’s actually a classic material in organic mattresses. It’s springy and durable, meaning it will provide comfort and ventilation for years to come. However, it’s also biodegradable, meaning that once the mattress has reached the end of its lifespan it won’t be sitting in a landfill for decades, which is ideal for the environment.

For those who suffer allergies, long strand mane and tail horse hair is hypoallergenic. But what makes it stand out the most is it has naturally antibacterial, anti-fungal, and anti-mite properties. This is great for people with sensitivities. You won’t have to worry about coughing, sneezing, or other bad reactions, so you can sleep soundly.

Flax

Organic flax is a key ingredient if you want to sleep on a vegan mattress. Made up of fibers from the flax plant, it’s strong, soft, and flexible. It’s an extremely versatile material that offers support, wicks away moisture from hot sleepers, and removes noise, vibrations, and static electricity. On top of that, it’s a material that’s virtually waste-free, supporting an eco-friendly lifestyle as you dream green.

Materials Used in Traditional Mattresses

Many of the same materials found in organic mattresses, such as latex, wool and cotton, are also found in traditional beds. The only difference is that they are not organically farmed. This distinct difference means there is the potential for pesticides or other chemicals to be in them. Other traditional mattress materials include the following:

Foam

Foam is a very popular option in traditional mattresses these days, particularly memory foam. Memory foam is made in part with polyurethane, which is known to contribute to off-gassing. Off-gassing is the smell the memory foam mattress gives off after it is unwrapped. This is why many people choose to let it air out for a few days before sleeping on it. Memory foam is soft and molds to the body, which is great for reducing motion transfer in bed.

If you want to enjoy a foam mattress without much off-gassing, CertiPUR-US polyurethane foam is a good choice. It meets CertiPUR-US® standards for content, emissions, and durability, but has low VOCs. It’s also made without mercury, lead, formaldehyde, or heavy metals. This makes it a much better choice when you want a foam mattress. 

Meanwhile, gel-infused memory foam is a popular option for sleepers who tend to sweat during the night. The gel acts as a cooling agent to bring down the temperature of the mattress. It’s generally just one of many layers in the mattress, so it provides softness and cooling while the other layers provide extra support. 

Innerspring

Innerspring mattresses contain metal coils deep within it to provide comfort and support. Many organic mattresses have innerspring support as well. The difference is traditional innerspring mattresses also contain latex, wool or other materials to wrap around the innersprings, while organic mattresses use natural and organic versions of those same materials.

Densified Insulator Pads

While densified insulator pads can be found in the Organic Classic mattress, you’re more likely to find it as a material in the Traditional Collection. It provides high-quality support to prevent sagging or impressions, and also prevents motion transfer. Most of all, it’s made out of recycled materials. This shows that traditional mattresses can, indeed, be eco-friendly, even if they’re not necessarily organic.

Pros and Cons of Organic and Traditional Mattresses

Many people choose an organic mattress over a traditional mattress is to ensure that they are sleeping on a chemical-free bed. Organic mattresses are usually naturally hypoallergenic, making them ideal for people who suffer from allergies. Additionally, the materials used in organic mattresses are usually sustainably farmed and manufactured, which is an environmental factor important to many people.

Many organic mattresses are also naturally fire resistant, although some organic mattresses do contain the same flame retardants as traditional mattresses. Some people are allergic to the components of traditional beds and can be irritated by glues or other materials in them. However, traditional mattresses shouldn’t be discarded. They have a variety of support and comfort levels that might be preferable to your specific sleep needs.

Both organic and traditional mattresses are competitively priced, meaning it is possible to purchase an organic mattress that is less expensive than a traditional one. Gardner Mattress carries organic and traditional beds at a variety of competitive price points. There is definitely something for every budget to meet a shopper’s specific sleep needs.

Contact Gardner Mattress or visit our showrooms to speak with our knowledgeable staff. Try out our organic and traditional mattresses in-store today to decide which is better for you.